A Retraction Please: Do print or online media get it right, most?

Picture this recent scenario.

Biola University Associated Students (AS) stages the annual presidential election on a Tuesday and Wednesday, with voting officially over at 7 p.m. For our paper, The Chimes, this is ideal. When the results are tabulated late at night, we will spit out a decisive new headline announcing the winner. Though the news might leak out via the BUBBS network around 11 p.m., the rest of the sleeping student body will not know the news until they wake up on Thursday morning to read a fresh, breaking story on the front page of our beloved weekly, The Chimes.

But does news ever work out the way a journalist wants it to? I think not.



When the election happened a few weeks ago, and the news was phoned into The Chimes' office at 9:30 p.m., I was ecstatic. The victor won by a mere three votes, and students would get that story hot off the press in our newspaper.

But then things started tangling. In a whirlwind of activity, someone demanded a recount, someone discovered a loophole to invalidate the election and someone was un-declared president.

At 2 a.m., when we finally sent the paper to press, the decision was in limbo.

When the result was finalized at 11:49 a.m. the next day, students found out through BUBBS e-mails. The Chimes had not even arrived back from the printer and wouldn't come until 6:30 that night -- well after most students had left for spring break. So, over a week later, students picked up cold copies of The Chimes to read, above the fold, "Gibo's 3-vote presidential victory short-lived; Clarke requests recount, loophole may invalidate election."

The problem? Gibo won anyway. Clarke conceded. The three-vote margin was actually two in the end, and everyone at Biola knew it a week ago.

Cue raucous laughter.

It's a case study into why we need an online edition; it's a study on how the worst gaffes can be in print, not in the volatile, opinion-laced world of online journalism.

But just to be fair, let's see who wins in the war of accuracy -- the solid, tactile print edition or the slippery online editions and fluctuating blogosphere.

Online Accuracy - The Doubters

In traditional print media, the news cycle goes something like this:
gather gather gather gather gather gather gather NEWS rest rest...

The cycle is as up-and-down as a sine wave, mounting up in explosive pressure before bursting out in a flurry of newsprint and toner. Then there is rest before the gathering must begin again.

In the online media, the news cycle goes something like this:
GATHER NEWS GATHER NEWS GATHER NEWS
The problem
most traditional print journalists assign to online media is that in this relentlessly oscillating cycle, there is no room for the copy editing and delicate preparation that put the "reputable" in "reputable news outlet."

Basically, the accusation is that the infogathering is incomplete, and the news suffers, as such:
GATHER NEWS GATHENEWS GATHNEW GATNE GANE GN

Some critics have been labeling this a fatal flaw. In his Miami Herald column, Edward Wasserman asks if the breakneck cycle of breaking online news
"a bold new push for reporting that's hasty, fragmented and half-baked?" The Washington and Lee University professor of journalism ethics wonders if new multi-tasking practices -- assigning solo reporters to photograph and videotape events in addition to writing about them -- are simply "diverting energies away from the kind of richly detailed, thoughtful reporting that exemplifies the best of journalism."

He has a point. Reporters can get so wrapped up in the frenzied work of gathering news in multiple media formats that they can't devote time to produce masterful works of written journalism.

In a survey by USC's Online Journalism Review, University of Florida Journalism Professor Mindy McAdams also agrees that the quality of journalism often degrades in the online format.

That "cycle" has contributed to a laxness in fact-checking coupled with an overeagerness to get any "new" (not necessarly news) item online as quickly as possible. The effects are amplified by the perverse habit of online addicts to replicate every juicy morsel the instant they can -- which in some ways can be really stupid, because then you just have everyone copying everyone else. There's a silly sense of "Oo! Oo! I had it first this time!" that certainly reflects back on traditional journalism and the ego-stroking thrill of getting a real scoop -- for which hardly any of these online "revelations" qualify.'
Simon Waldman, online director of the UK's Guardian Unlimited online news source, sees that the nature of online journalism can lend itself to getting the story wrong -- and subsequently, a lack of credibility.
Get the story right. Get it out there as quickly as possible. Do it in that order, and you will have no problems. Do it the other way round, and after a while you won't be taken seriously. It doesn't matter if you're a blogger with a dozen readers a day, or a major news organization with a million or more.
So how are online journalists keeping their edge while also keeping their ethical standards? At this point, most don't really know. In an article titled "
Helter Skelter No More:
An Evolving Guidebook for Online Ethics," Bob Steele analyzes a survey of online journalists taken by the Poynter Institute.

Among the questions the survey posed was "How do you address such issues currently?" The results show that there's not much being done. These professionals gave these replies:

  • "Right now it's a bit of a wing and a prayer."
  • "Right now it's a bit of trial and error."
  • "We struggle with the questions as they arise, on the fly. The issues are evolving as the medium evolves, and the answers are evolving, too."
  • "We deal with them on a case by case, and, frankly, haphazard basis."
  • "We're making it up as we go, and in the future we'd like to have it all figured out."
  • "We are mostly addressing the issues as they arise, but it seems that the technical advances are ahead of our thinking or our creation of systems to cope with the change."
  • "We currently address these issues case-by-case, erring on the side of caution. In the future, I'd like to create a mission statement and 'guidelines' -- not mandates -- that both editorial and advertising can live with."
It seems that online outlets are working through the bugs of the budding new medium. After several years, consumers can expect to see a system that more closely complies with ethical standards. But at the same time, it may be that our perception of propriety might change with the times.

For example, before the printing press was invented, an individual's knowledge base was limited to the lore of oral tradition and confined to the very wealthy who could afford scribes and manuscripts. Once the press was invented, knowledge was a cheaper commodity. The wealthy no longer held absolute sway over the ignorant and social mobility increased. For aristocrats, this was doubtlessly frightening. There were likely "glitches" in abundance during the early years of the press. Information probably got into the wrong hands, presses printed inflammatory and erroneous information. But in retrospect, few consider this invention problematic. The benefits that stem from the open flow of information far outweigh the risks of information falling into the wrong hands.

In the same way, the internet has changed our society's paradigm. Information is available so freely that it is bound to get into the wrong hands and much of it is bound to be erroneous. But in retrospect, such a vibrant flow of information will be normal, and society will view the development of the internet, almost universally, a good thing.

With that in mind, let's consider what proponents are saying about the accuracy of the internet.

Wikipedia Syndrome: How the Web can go Wrong, and Why We Should be Willing to Take that Risk


It's the cardinal rule of today's research paper: don't cite Wikipedia.

The user-edited encyclopedia is a professor's nightmare. Created, augmented and updated by God-only-knows-who, the site can be as easily tweaked by a neurosurgeon as by the punk kid across the street.

But just because it's citizen-produced doesn't necessarily mean it's inaccurate. A study in the science magazine Nature found that the professionals will get the facts wrong almost as often as the non-commissioned contributors.

The same situation goes for journalism. Just because it's online doesn't mean it's inaccurate or inferior. An established outlet of online journalism can offer the late-breaking news that print sources could only dream of offering -- in that sense, it's superior. Also, errors can be corrected quicker -- in that sense, it's more accurate.

In examining the internet as a whole, I must concede that the internet's accuracy is shoddy. How many bloggers propagate rumors, fail to cite sources, or blatantly lie? The blogosphere is inundated with hundreds of millions of "news sources," and the average of those will lean toward the side of unfounded opinions.

At the same time, this doesn't mean that all internet news outlets ignore ethical standards. It just means that readers need to be more discerning about which sources they trust.

The truth is, more people than ever are using the internet as a news source -- and these statistics aren't changing anytime soon. According to "Online News," a March 2006 report from the Pew Internet & American Life Project, high-speed internet users (like those at Biola) are reading news online frequently.

The results show that:
􀂄 71% of high-powered users get news online on the average day—three times the
rate of other high-speed users;
􀂄 59% get news on the average day from local TV;
􀂄 53% get news on the typical day from radio;
􀂄 52% get news on the average day from national TV newscasts;
􀂄 43% get news on the average day from the local paper;
􀂄 21% get news on the average day from a national newspaper.

With an ever-growing number of online contributors -- and this burgeoning contingent of online consumers -- we will need to accept the risk of extreme, flagrantly erroneous information on some sites. When it comes to accuracy online, Steve Outing of the Poynter Institute points out society's helplessness: "Control bloggers?" he asks. "Impossible, I say, unless they all get hired by media companies."

But the risk of errors shouldn't keep users or journalists away, Outing said in a November 2004 post on Poynter's website:

"How about accepting that the media world has changed, and that mainstream news
organizations are powerless to control the flow of information (whether it be
leaked exit-poll numbers or graphic videos of beheadings)? All mainstream
editors can do is live by their own standards -- to keep their own houses in
order."
And in the process of building high standards, Kelly McBride of the Poynter Institute says watchdog blogs can only help.

"Blogs have formed to monitor individual newsrooms and even certain
journalists," she wrote. "In response, journalists will get better and tougher."
Outing suggests that "the real story, I think, is that mainstream journalists from here on out have an army of citizen "reporters" and fact-checkers to watch over their work," he said in a September, 2004 Poynter blog post name 'Blog and Media Accuracy.' "I suggest that journalists view this in a positive light: Citizen watchdogging and, yes, assistance can make traditional reporters' work better and more accurate."
The bottom line is, the online conversation -- which encompasses online news -- is taking place whether we like it or not. There will undoubtedly be leaks, opinion dressed as fact and misleading statements involved in this new media wave.
But journalists and citizens need not spurn online media as a result. It is, on average, less factually accurate than an established traditional publication. But it is more accurate because it is including more voices in the Grand Conversation, bringing the underrepresented a medium through which to communicate.


CLASS ASSIGNMENT//Ugly Websites: Are Christian Colleges Selling Themselves Short on the Net?


When I explored
Biola University as a prospective student, I saw it first on printed advertisements. But it was the website where I spent the most time, weaving through links and menus until I knew exactly what the dorm floor plans looked like and how the honors program stacked up.

Now, when people ask why I chose this school, I refer to the website -- specifically the
first-year web journals for which I would later become a contributor. I remember reading the journal of a guy named Jeremy. He was an out-of-stater with an expansive vocabulary and an unmistakable heart for Christ. I remembered that I wanted, someday, to write like Jeremy did, to be as grounded as Jeremy was.

And so I chose Biola, largely because of what I found at biola.edu.

But I have to question the look and functionality of our current website. If prospective students are choosing between several great, Christian schools, the website could make or break that decision. We need to be wise stewards of our net presence.

So in this series of posts, I'll be looking at Biola's site in comparison to other universities -- schools that would be on a prospective's finalist list. Are we projecting a good image? Or are we selling ourselves short?

Let's take a look.

But first,
read what Britain's The Guardian has to say about the disconnect between teens and unwieldy university websites.

What Makes a Great Site

Function

A guy named Ken Kelleher did some
research on university websites a few years back. From his study, he came up with a few important bullet points in creating a functional, navigable site.

The biggest problem, Kelleher says, is an ailment known as ICCMUT. No, it's not a disease. It actually stands for Immense Content Challenges with Multiple User Types.

Think about it. As much as I'd like to think the world revolves around current students, that group is just a sliver of the pie. Universities have large and diverse audiences that include:

  • the prospective undergrad student (the picky kids frowning on the campus tour)
  • the current undergrad student (me and 3,000 of my closest friends, all vying to get on the web version of BUBBS e-mail)
  • the prospective grad student (the earnest pastor-to-be prayerfully checking out Talbot)
  • the current grad student (the earnest pastor-to-be prayerfully attending Talbot and taking up way too much study space in the library)
  • alumni (tearfully reminiscing about their alma mater)
  • current faculty (signing up for workshops, maybe? I dunno...)
  • current staff (uhhh...)
  • parents (being nosy)
  • visitors (who heard the name on Nightline... or maybe in regards to missing silverware)
  • potential staff and faculty (checking out the doctrinal statement)
  • local community visitors interested in news, events, etc (Eaglesports fans)
  • researchers (journalists)
  • investors (laudable donors)

Kelleher points out that "Users are interested in accessing information relevant to their purpose in an efficient manner that is user friendly." A visitor wants thorough information and they want it fast. Oh, and the scenery had better be pretty along the way.

The best way to be user-friendly, according to this research, is to have a PRIMARY NAVIGATION system, with a parent navigation bar (fixed categories running along the top) and a child navigation bar (a sidebar which changes depending on what page you're on).

And second, a site needs a UTILITY NAVIGATION system, which includes necessities like a search feature, campus map, index, etc. Though it's a few years old and the design is dated, here's an example of how to structure a site to allow for natural navigation.

Form

But after function comes form. The site needs to catch the eye, focus the eye and guide the eye. All those searchable lists and all that text need to be arranged legibly and elegantly. Patrick Lynch and Sarah Horton explain how in their Web Style Guide.

Now that the rules are set, let's examine some of the top contenders among University sites.

And just for a sneak peek, check out one of the sites voted Best University Website of 2006 by the Web Marketing Association.

Critiques of the Five Most Popular CCCU Sites in California

The following statistical data is from Alexa Information Systems' ranking system, which ranks sites from around the world by keeping a daily record of REACH (the percentage of internet users worldwide that visit a site) and TRAFFIC RANK (how many visits a site gets in comparison to all other sites). Here is data about the most popular sites of the ten California-based schools that are members of the Coalition of Christian Colleges and Universities. These figures are an average of traffic between 2/12/07 and 5/12/07.

Information with asterisks (*) comes from Mike Ward's 2002 texbook, Journalism Online, published by Focal Press. Information with two asterisks (**) comes from Ken Kelleher's research.




1. School: Biola University
Reaches: .00115% of internet users worldwide
Traffic Rank: 110,914 in world

Biola's site is not the most visually striking of these five. With no Flash media or dominating photos, the home page would likely not win the favor of Dave Siegel, author of How to Make Killer Web Sites.* The goal is primarily to inform -- rather than impress -- visitors. Siegel, on the other hand, encourages designers to create "virtual experiences," leading visitors down a linear path through a "front door" and various, tantalizing "entry tunnels" into the site.

With a guileless listing of links, a white background and Arial type, Biola's home pages are clear and content-based. Web expert Jakob Nielsen, whose philosophy is "remove graphic, increase traffic," would appreciate the university's focus on concise bits of text and brief paragraphs rather than colorful photos.*


2. School: Azusa Pacific University
Reaches: .00087% of internet
Traffic Rank: 125,740

A Flash slideshow of bold, striking photography dominates Azusa's site. This type of cutting-edge design adheres to Mike Ward's principal of "getting a user's attention when they first arrive," with the idea that each subsequent page will "take greater responsibility for holding the visitors' interest."*

The site also does a good job of funneling visitors based on their self-identity.** Prospective students are immediately drawn to their respective site regions, away from the technical language of, say, the faculty pages.

One of the site's downfalls is its use of light-colored text on a dark grey background. It's nowhere near as easy to read as Biola's black-on-white scheme. This page would also take longer to load on computers with slower modems, frustrating users with low-speed internet service.


3. School: Westmont (Santa Barbara)
Reaches: .00039% of internet
Traffic Rank: 233,952

While Westmont's site is clean and links are unmistakable, it is overly symmetrical and hardly artistic. The design does not take into account the power of contrast.* Had the page distinguished at least on of its columns with a color besides white, the site could better guide the reader through the page.

As Kelleher encourages, the page presents navigation bars horizontally and vertically. The horizontal bar presents "utility navigation," including essentials such as a campus map and and an ever-present pathway to the home page (centralized "home" link).** Ward applauds sites that allow the visitor to freely roam their pages without fear of "getting lost" and losing connection from the home pages.*


4. School: Vanguard (Costa Mesa)
Reaches: .00048% of internet
Traffic Rank: 253,887

Vanguard's site is slick and boasts a fresh, clean design. A Flash slideshow of striking, dominant photos carries on below a brief message about the school's mission and some common links. The design utilizes elements of contrast and repetition, which helps the visitor quickly distinguish between the news, calendar and menu sections.*

Critics of Vanguard's site might argue that the school's design distracts from clarity. Users can instantly read an Arial typeface with underlining on links. This design, however, opts for a more obscure, elegant font. It is more aesthetically pleasing, but compromises instant clarity and familiarity.


5.
School: Cal Baptist (Riverside)
Reaches: .0003% of internet
Traffic Rank: 321,142

Cal Baptist keeps it site simple, with a dramatic background photo. Though the design is clean and striking, users are given a limited palette of options, forcing them to guess where to find features like a campus map. This breaks Steve Krug's cardinal rule of web design -- "don't make me think."* The site would do visitors a favor if more links were available on the home page.

Why I Strive

I was reading the Heidelberg Catechism today and it reminded me of why I'm striving for excellence in journalism.

Q. What does the Lord require of you in [the eighth] commandment (do not steal)?

A. That I do whatever I can for my neighbor's good


ooops. poking nicole in the eye during duck duck goose wasn't exactly "for my neighbor's good."

...that I treat others as I would like them to treat me...

I want to treat my bf, my buddy Jason and my future roommate like I want to be treated.

...and that I work faithfully...


In the tie is my role model. He showed me how to work faithfully and excellently.

...so that I may share with those in need."

I want to do it for the sake of my coworkers, these lovely ladies.

I love the idea that "do not steal" means more than "don't shoplift." It also means proactively doing what you can to be able to give the most to your neighbors.

It reminds me of journalism -- and my neighbors pictured above.

I'm not striving for myself. I'm not looking for accolades of my own.I am working for something greater -- for my God, for my neighbors.
I am putting in excellence because I dare not discount the grace by which you gave me the ability to work.
I am putting in excellence because I dare not sell my friends short.
I am putting in excellence because I want the best for my school and for the students who will become journalists after me. I want them to be equipped to change the world.

Lord, you have been faithful, and the least I can do is strive for faithfulness to you.

Gee, your prom pictures turned out really cute.

you knew so little, felt so much
and flashbulbs caught that youthful blush
silk fell smooth on sandaled feet
and flashbulbs lumined perfect teeth

you thought so little, loved so much
you immortalized that flimsy crush
like a heroine or nymph divine
you stole the sting away from time

High School all over again.

On my spring break visit back to high school, and high school fundraiser functions, I reunited with.....


The best ladies of the band.

Clarinet. Bassoon. Flute. Flute.

It was awesome.

Hope


In this world you will have tribulations

But take heart for I have overcome the world.

About this blog

The life, travels and journalistic adventures of Michelle