Few answers to questions of war ... and ethics of war photography

As debate swirls about the Associated Press' decision to distribute images of a marine after he was mortally wounded by a rocket propelled grenade in Afghanistan, I'm torn. The embedded photographer waited until after the marine's family was notified of his death and after his memorial service. The photo was released in a tasteful, narrated audio slideshow with a 1,700-word print article and extensive journal entries from the photographer herself.

But when she showed the family the photo in advance, the marine's father told her not to publish it -- twice. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates wrote an impassioned letter imploring the AP to reconsider the image's publication, calling the decision to distribute it against the family's will "appalling" and a violation of human decency.

I don't know if I could do what photographer Julie Jacobson did, but after working at AP, I have a few thoughts.

1. This is not a TMZ image. This is not the kind of picture that some salacious news site driven by the gruesome, the scandalous, the sensational paid $50,000 for. TMZ finds a picture of a battered Rihanna and slaps it on its blog-style home page. Millions of fans flock to it to gawk at it, and TMZ is on the phone calling up advertisers: "So, you wanna put an ad for the lap-band on the right side of the Rihanna picture? Yeah, it's going to be ten times the standard rate." Cha-ching.

The AP does not get the advertising gains from photos like this. They get money from member media outlet subscribing to years' worth of stories. The money flow is so indirect that the photographer will never see a spike in her paycheck.

In any tragedy, paparazzi emerge from the woodwork with repulsive merchandise: A picture of Michael Jackson's lifeless body as it wheels through the E.R. doors. A photo of model Jasmine Fiore's body in a suitcase. No thank you.

By contrast, AP staff photographers gather images because it's their job. And they accept a meager salary whether they photograph a flower or a death in Fallujah. Money is not the motivation.

2. This is war. This is history. Most crime photos are beyond the realm of decency. I remember feeling sick when I opened a Costa Rican newspaper to see a row of bullet-riddled corpses after a drug war execution. It was gratuitous. Perhaps it showed a piece of the cold reality of criminal life, but more than anything, it made a great photo for page A2.

Wars like the one in Afghanistan are daily news. They're the subject of international diplomacy talks and will mark the pages of history to time immortal. This is no freak accident, no crime involving John Doe private citizen, but an official member of a delegation of taxpayer-funded, government-sanctioned armed forces.

As journalists, it is our ethical obligation to enlighten audiences with accurate accounts of historic events. Death is an inextricable piece in the puzzle of war, and we cannot turn a blind, oversensitized eye. We owe it to history and the millions of Americans tied to this war to tell the truth that they might make an appropriate decision in response.

At the same time, context is vital. The picture of Rihanna, or the picture of the drug war slayings, jilted the reader with little more than a shallow paragraph of context. With great images comes great responsibility, and I appreciate that the AP used every medium possible to reflect on the significance of the image and the significance of death in wartime. That treatment moves Americans forward.

3. Death is personal. I weigh the prior considerations with my strong conviction that death is the most intimate moment in a person's life. I hated the media circus directly after Michael Jackson's death because people forgot MJ was a person. We dehumanized him when it became more about a scoop than a tragic loss of life.

As the primary carriers of the marine's legacy, the family should have a say in these times of grief. His death affects no one so profoundly, pervasively and permanently as his family.

----

At the end of that awful day, what Julie Jacobson had on her hands were images heavy with the gravity of history. She and the AP were forced to decide: publish or don't publish? I don't know there will ever be a right decision to that question because there are no right answers to the ages-old questions of war: Why this marine? Why is there suffering?

In war, and history, and journalistic ethics, we may never know peace

You made the night to fall

And I thank you for the night
That you made it to fall,
Not flick on and off like
Our shoddy copies
You made it to linger
On the edge of possibility
And drip into tomorrow
Succulent and sweet
Even the trees stand back
And melt to black
Against the backdrop
Of the burning sky
They partake
In the living praise
And know their glory
Is their stark relief against it
You did too much
In making day’s death
Devastating, beautiful
It arrests me:
The way you
Tell me no
By making my eyes drunk
With afterglow

Her Inglorious Death

It’s salacious and delicious
The kind of story that could make a script
A bombshell, a pinup
And her mysterious death.
My editor wants 130 words
And I better write the good stuff
Like the dumpster she was in
When they found her dead
And suddenly it hits
As I describe her body folded in a suitcase
That she’s somebody’s baby
And when her daddy reads the paper tomorrow
My words will stab him like a knife
But the papers will run it
The anchors will fake a frown
As they read it aloud.
Inglorious death, oh
You are the glory
Of this soulless
Thing I do --
The news.

Goodbye to my Chimes


Nothing will ever compare to the memories working on The Chimes. No group will get me quite the way The Chimes did. Work will never be as fun as it is on The Chimes; our product may never bring as much satisfaction as does The Chimes right now.

To all others, I guess it must just be a student paper. To us, it's people and laughter and belonging. It's mission and motivation and purpose. It's going to send a lot more people into the journalism industry than it can contain, but they'll be great journalists; I know it.

How did I get so lucky as to be part of this inspiring and embracing group? God put me here, that's for sure. I hate to say goodbye and move on, as the memories stay frozen in time and newsprint. But what a sweet ending tonight was. It was a warm and high note I know I'll treasure forever.

[The insider blog: here]

Nate the Christian Windshield Repairman



If you read my post on Chris the Christian plumber, you're well aware of my dad's insistence on hiring Christians for just about any household repair project.

Fortunately, when we realized that the glaring gash in my windshield was not just a visual impediment (sometimes, the sun glints off the crack, producing a blinding prism-like effect), but an invitation for a fix-it ticket, my dad acquiesced and decided to replace the glass.

To our eternal delight, we were able to find a replacement in a mobile windshield repair service -- and there was a Jesus fish in the Yellow Pages ad.

And so today we had not only the acute privilege of getting a new windshield for just $179, but also the joy of meeting Nate the Christian Windshield Repairman. What, you ask, is the difference between a Christian windshield repairman and a non-Christian? Why, the Third Day CD blaring from the work truck. The bumper sticker saying Twin Cities Church. And the joy my dad gets from talking church with him.

Which leads me to a similar conclusion as the plumbing post -- I'd never let an atheist touch this windshield.

"Does God Exist?" Debate at Biola

After reading Melissa's post about the William Lane Craig-Christopher Hitchens debate at Biola last weekend, I thought I'd throw in my two cents.

Hitchens says he wants to be an atheist because he loves freedom. As someone who has traveled the world reporting on injustices and oppression committed in the name of religion, he has the right to come to that conclusion. Nothing is more repulsive than the misogyny, the slavery, the brainwashing and war advanced by religious groups -- except the fact they're claiming to do it in God's name. Hitchens, thank you for hating that, because I know God hates that too.

The problem is that a life of atheism is not a life of freedom -- it's just a new kind of oppression. You are no longer bound by the shackles of "religious ignorance," but you are left with a void, a life of no eternal significance, a short-sighted purpose. At the end of the day, there is no redemption for the sinner; there is no vindication for the victim. Life is wretched and cruel, and we're all alone in our despair.

Freedom in Christ is redemption. It's the assurance that even the pain and agony of our short lives is being woven into a tapestry of grand proportions. We don't see the sense in it now; but in the grand scheme of God's redemptive plan, it has been worked out for the good of those who love him. We see just the threads of that tapestry; God is doing work beyond our lifetime to restore his fallen creation, and some day the senseless will make sense.

Hitchens would call this wishful thinking, but I'm thankful William Lane Craig offered compelling evidence why our faith is reasonable, why this narrative of audacious hope is reasonable.

In the end, we as humans don't understand freedom. We think of freedom in small and fallen ways, like the women's liberation and free love movement, like the hedonism of college life. We find that our best stabs at freedom -- our best attempts to shrug off the "captivity" of the Christian life -- merely shutter us in our own personal prisons and cut us off from the meaning of the big picture. It's a lonely and shriveled existence, and we can't understand how in the world we got there.

My prayer is that the "Does God Exist?" debate puts a pebble in the shoes of Hitchens and the other atheists and religionists who have experienced false freedom, false enlightenment. I hope their quest will lead them straight to a cross and an empty tomb.

My 22nd Birthday

It was a splendid 22nd birthday for me -- and everyone seemed to be right on track by sending their birthday greetings in Spanish!

The house had a Mexican fiesta, and with the help of some of the more culinarily gifted members, we put together homemade carne asada tacos, spicy rice and cheesy beans.

For one of the rarest moments, we all gathered together and ate dinner at our table -- all ten of us. No boys, no guests. Just the ten of us laughing and talking together. It was such a beautiful time. Often, we get caught up entertaining the guests that frequent the house, making them feel comfortable and making them dinner or coffee. It's wonderful, but it's good to be able to talk face to face with the incredible women who compose the Decadox. In our hustle and bustle of hospitality, we can take each other for granted.

In light of my coming-of-age, I want to write a resolution for my 22nd year:
> Though I may be young and healthy, I want to remember those who aren't. I want to learn their history, value their wisdom, and engage with their world. In this country, we are so obsessed with youth and beauty that we scorn the contributions of our elders. I want to honor that this year. I want to honor the people and the places from which I came, because I am not a self-made woman, and so much that I am is owed to those who have gone before me.

So that is all.

An argument for women in Biola's AS presidency

Edmund Burke once said, “All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.” Let me reframe that for today: “All that is necessary for the triumph of mediocrity of AS is that good women do nothing.”

This year’s ballot selection was disappointing, not because the candidates were bad, but because so many of Biola’s incredible, intelligent, ambitious, competent female leaders were absent. In fact, it hasn’t been since the 1994 that a woman has taken the AS presidency. That’s a 15-year drought of executive female leadership.

But it’s not just a recent drought. Records aren’t complete, but since 1926, the year AS was founded, only three women appear in the annals of executive leadership: Ruth Farquharson in 1928, Carol Hulgus in 1986, and Jennifer Cowen in 1994. By comparison, 62 percent of the undergraduate student body is female. It’s safe to say that the people representing the interests and concerns of the student body are not representative of the student body.

Why is that? Why is it that women currently constitute ¾ of the executive leadership team in AS? That they’ve been presidents of SMU, directors of ministries, presidents of clubs, editors of The Chimes, The Point and The Biolan, and yet haven’t taken such a weighty role as the AS presidency?

There are a number of reasons for this “glass ceiling” in AS. First, women haven’t seen a role model in recent history. If they have never seen a woman take on this responsibility and successfully execute it, the image of what it means to be “presidential” persists – you must be an attractive, white male with senatorial experience. Voters tend to choose someone who “looks presidential,” and it will take a non-traditional candidate to re-draw that image in the minds of students.

Second, some women self-eliminate when they buy into wrongheaded biblical interpretation that women should leave significant leadership roles to men. Even if you are against women in the pastorate, AS is certainly not the church and such antiquated, culturally-enforced stereotypes only serve to debilitate and deprive such an organization.

The last thing this school needs is to elect a candidate simply because she is a woman – that would be patronizing. What we do need, however, is to nurture women who show leadership gifts and encourage them to run for this position next year.

Here’s to all the freshman women out there: Start by praying about this. Has God gifted you with administrative ability, people skills and a love for Biola? Then why isn’t AS on your radar? Some of the most talented women on campus aren’t in this post right now because they never had the dream from the outset and never prepared themselves for the role.

Second, prepare yourself. Seek out positions within AS as soon as possible, whether that be a seat in the senate or a hired service chair position. Work hard at it. And don’t get discouraged if you don’t make it the first time around. Also, take on roles of executive leadership that require you to be the primary decision maker and exercise creativity. Leading a mission trip or a club is a good place to start.

The glass ceiling needs to shatter, not because men are bad leaders and women need to prove themselves. It needs to shatter because the ceiling might be holding back the competent, humble, visionary woman AS needs to take it to new heights.
After all, nobody wins win good women do nothing.

Reconciliation

Tonight I'll be going to SCORR -- Student Congress on Racial Reconciliation, which is held annually at Biola. I've gone in past years and had different reactions every time. The archives of this blog are proof.

SCORR, especially tonight's Worship Mosaic, is a pinnacle of beautiful worship. You see people from different countries, wearing brilliant colors and foreign costumes, dancing and singing and praising God in other languages. One of the themes in years past was "On Earth as it is in Heaven," hinting at how diverse and joyful heaven will be once things like race are not liabilities, but appreciated expressions of God's beneficent plan.

But something so extravagant must have a counterpoint. SCORR is also pretty gritty, pretty depressing, pretty much a downer at times. People are angry and accusatory when they talk about the way they feel because of their skin color. Some people say whites (or "the dominant culture") doesn't and will never understand the minority culture.

I feel helpless, accused, and backed into a corner.

I look at state universities, pluralistic places where women walk around in hijabs and the student body is a potpourri of skin tones, religions and ethnicities. Why does the race issue seem so much more explosive among the most global institution in the world -- the church? Are these secular institutions that much more advanced that they are "post-race"? They're past these problems? I guess it's possible.

Or maybe it's that they've never reconciled with other races -- never engaged enough to conflict -- because they've never been challenged by such provocative mandates as "Go ye therefore and teach all nations," or loving the Samaritans.

Nothing as beautiful as reconciliation ever came easy and cleanly. Does a man who cheats on his wife reclaim his marriage by just standing by? Did Germany and the Allies get over their differences in a night? Did fallen man and a perfect God reunite painlessly?

No. And I know if we seek something like reconciliation, it will come at a cost. My only worry is that we won't have the stamina to get there.

Chimes Resolutions

Just wanted to update on the previous post -- since I've been a blogging delinquent as of late due to my broken-down computer.

God really came through for The Chimes. We were in a panic about advertising people and sports people and graphic designers, but one by one, the right people showed up. I think the team really is stronger and more cohesive than ever, and it shows.

Another great thing is our new apprentices. I wanted the transition from this year's staff to next year's staff to be fluid, and for all the wisdom and experience we've developed this year to pass on to next year's staff. I'm starting to see the fruit of that plan in the form of a half-dozen enthusiastic apprentices who have been helping staff members and taking on their own projects.

Thanks for your prayers. There are ups and downs while being the editor, and I know it's only by God's grace that it works the way it's supposed to.

About this blog

The life, travels and journalistic adventures of Michelle